The best pillows in the US for hot sleepers, side sleepers and everyone in between

  
  


It’s pretty common advice that you should invest in anything that connects you to the ground. Most people think of shoes, tires and mattresses. However, I think people overlook things such as socks and pillows. The humble pillow can spell the difference between a fantastic night’s sleep and tossing and turning until dawn.

Goldilocks and I are on the same page. You need a pillow that isn’t too soft, hard, cold or hot. It needs to be just right.

***

***

Why you should trust me

I have been testing and reviewing products for more than 13 years, including for the Guardian’s Filter US since October 2025, with items such as bath towels, dryer balls and space heaters. I got my start at a product-testing lab where I tested household products under a combination of established and bespoke standards, and I specialized in washing machines and fabric care, and helped develop sleep lab protocols. I’m all about making sure products live up to what is advertised on the tin and provide good value. Plus, I love naps.

How I tested pillows

A good pillow should be able to provide support without feeling hard and be soft without completely enveloping you. To test this, I placed a 20lb weight on each pillow’s center and measured the amount of compression.

Whether you’re a hot or cold sleeper, your pillow is a big factor in whether you get a comfortable night’s rest. To test each pillow’s temperature regulation, I placed heating pads in the microwave for 15 seconds in order to bring them up to around 100F (roughly body temperature). The heating pad went between each pillow and a folded towel for 20 minutes, then I used a thermal camera to measure heat dissipation.

For any pillows with specific claims, I spent time measuring each pillow and researching what each brand claimed their pillows could do, and did extra tests to see if they lived up to the hype.

***

<em>Best pillow overall:</em> Coop Original Adjustable Pillow

Coop
Original Adjustable Pillow
none-selected
Coop Original Adjustable Pillow product photo
  • Coop $67
  • Amazon $71
$67 at Coop $71 at Amazon

Why we love it: The Coop Original Adjustable Pillow checks all the main boxes. It’s an adjustable model, meaning it comes with a bag of memory foam cubes that you place into the pillow to customize its height to help align your head, neck and body. The medium firmness of the foam feels supportive without being hard. Also, the cubed, cross-cut nature of the filling requires less fluffing and fuss than a down pillow.

(If you’re interested in latex, copper or cooling gel, the brand offers different types of filling to buy separately.)

Having slept on this Coop for years on my own and three days for testing, I forgot that it was there after a time since the support for my neck and shoulders felt so seamless. It essentially feels like an extension of the mattress, letting me sleep oblivious to the fact there is a pillow there at all. That is why I think the Coop is the best option. Most people just want a good night’s sleep and not have to think about their pillow. The adjustable nature means you can make sure the pillow contours to your body and the fill material is robust enough to resist compressing throughout the night.

It’s a shame that: When you first take the Coop out of its box, it will smell terrible. The off-gassing period will take a few days. Also, if you’re the kind of person whose ideal pillow makes you feel like sleeping on a cloud, the Coop isn’t for you.

Fill type: Memory foam and microfiber

Case type: 60% polyester, 40% bamboo-derived viscose

***

<em>Best down alternative pillow:</em>Quince Premium Down Alternative Pillow

Quince
Premium Down Alternative Pillow
none-selected
Quince Premium Down Alternative Pillow
  • Quince $40
$40 at Quince

Why we love it: If I had to describe the Quince Premium Down Alternative Pillow in one word, it would be “elevated”, quite literally. It’s about 7.5in thick, stuffed with a very dense microgel and ultra-fine polyester fibers. Back sleepers take note: the loft will lift your head quite high up. I personally felt my head was out of alignment with the rest of my body, but your mileage may vary. However, I think bed readers will enjoy how well the Quince pillow props you up when leaning against your headboard.

The exterior is made from sateen, a cotton fabric that resists wrinkling and feels smooth, with a double-stitched hem. When you combine that with a dense filling, you get a pillow that doesn’t require a lot of fluffing and fussing. Also, this pillow’s sheer mass translates to higher heat dissipation – there’s so much space, you’ll find a cool spot.

If you’re interested in a big pillow that elevates your head and shoulders or an additional pillow to grasp for side sleeping, the Quince Premium Down Alternative Pillow is worth checking out.

It’s a shame that: This pillow is not easily adjustable. One of its greatest strengths is that it’s stuffed it to the rafters with filling, but that also means if you’re someone who likes to shift their pillow around, the Quince Premium Down Alternative Pillow will not oblige.

Fill type: 100% polyester

Case type: 100% cotton sateen

***

<em>Best down pillow:</em> Brooklinen Down Pillow

Brooklinen
Down Pillow
none-selected
Brooklinen Down Pillow
  • Brooklinen $127
$127 at Brooklinen

Why we love it: Duck feathers are a classic pillow filling, and the Brooklinen Down Pillow is a prime example of why. It’s soft, cozy and filled with premium, high-grade Canadian duck down and down feather fibers (incomplete and broken feathers). The exterior is made from sateen cotton, which enhances the soft feel – and the feathers are Downmark certified, which means the down is gathered sustainably and humanely.

Sleeping on this pillow is a cozy experience. After about a minute, my head sank immediately into the surface, molding to the shape of my skull. I’d describe the feeling as cloud-like.

However, being enveloped by a pillow did make my head warm. Heat retention is one of the main reasons to buy a product with real down. It is why jackets made for the Arctic are filled with goose down. The second reason is weight – light as a feather is quite literal in this case. A light and fluffy pillow works well with anyone who likes to readjust their pillow throughout the night, such as someone who switches between stomach and side sleeping. As a back sleeper, I felt like this pillow cupped my ears too much, as if it was squeezing my head.

Overall, the Brooklinen Down Pillow 2.0 is perfect for someone who wants hygge – the Danish word describing a sense of warm, cozy contentment – while they sleep.

It’s a shame that: Since real down is a luxury, it comes with a high-end price tag. If you’re used to paying less than $50 a pillow, the Brooklinen Down Pillow might be too rich for your blood.

Fill type: 100% down feathers and feather fibers

Case type: 100% cotton

***

<em>Best pillow for hot sleepers:</em> Nest Easy Breather Pillow

Nest
Easy Breather Pillow
none-selected
Nest Easy Breather Pillow
  • Nest $83
$83 at Nest

Why we love it: Unlike the other options on this list, the Nest Easy Breather Pillow feels different right out of the box – it’s cold to the touch. A lot of that comes from the pillow’s unique (and removable) fill of cut foam and breathable fibers. Thermal imaging showed that the pillow’s surface is about 2F cooler than the ambient temperature. During testing, the Easy Breather proved to be one of the best for hot sleepers, wicking away 1.2F per minute during our heat test.

Like the Coop, you can also remove the fill to adjust the loft height. If you decide to try this one out as is, fresh out of the box, it stands about 8.5in tall, which will probably lift your head a hair too high, but your mileage may vary – and it’s always better to have too much removable filling than not enough. I would suggest following Nest’s recommendations to remove about 25% of the fill for back sleepers and 33% for stomach sleepers.

I enjoyed sleeping on the Nest Easy Breather Pillow. After adjusting to the desired loft height, it’s supportive without being hard and never made me feel sweaty.

It’s a shame that: It is very similar to the Coop Adjustable Pillow, but slightly more expensive.

Fill type: 80% memory foam, 20% polyester fiber

Case type: 49% polyester, 49% icecore fabric , 2% spandex

***

<em>Best budget pillow:</em>Beckham Hotel Collection Pillow

Beckham
Hotel Collection Gel Pillow
none-selected
Beckham Hotel Collection Pillow
  • Amazon $60
$60 for pack of two at Amazon

Why we love it: The Beckham Hotel Collection Gel Pillows would not be out of place atop a bed in a five-star hotel suite – fluffy, like one of those Japanese pancakes. While you might think that a luxury experience would be pricey, Beckham’s pillows are surprisingly affordable – more so than the majority of pillows in this guide.

What’s nice about this pillow is its versatility. It’s firm enough that it provides neck support, but soft enough that your head sinks into the surface, a Goldilocks solution that results in a pillow that I can only describe as huggable. In terms of cooling, I found it to be relatively cool when side sleeping, but if you’re sleeping on your back, the gel pillow will mold around you, trapping heat.

It’s a shame that: I found that the Beckham Hotel Collection Gel Pillow requires a lot of readjusting. The filling is very squishy and not very dense, so it tends to shift around a lot during the night.

Fill type: 100% polyester

Case type: 100% cotton

***

<em>Best latex:</em> Saatva Latex Pillow

Saatva
Latex Pillow
none-selected
Saatva Latex Pillow
  • Saatva $165
  • Amazon $165
$165 at Saatva $165 at Amazon

Why we love it: Latex pillows offer excellent support and good temperature regulation, and they are known to be super durable. The Saatva Latex Pillow is a prime example. It’s a good blend of soft yet supportive. Also, since the interior is a mix of latex and polyester, it’s not too dense. This is a pillow you can fluff and readjust throughout the night.

Overall, I found the Saatva checks all the right boxes. I never felt too hot while sleeping on it. During our heating test, it wicked away about 1F per minute, putting it near the top of the heap. The standard-size model I tested was comfortable while on my back and acceptable on my side.

It’s a shame that: I have a sensitive nose, and even after a week, I could still smell the latex odor through my pillowcase.

Fill type: 59% polyester, 41% latex foam

Case type: 100% cotton

***

Everything else we tested

Purple Harmony Pillow

Purple
Harmony Pillow
none-selected
Purple Harmony Pillow
  • Purple $194
  • Amazon $194
$194 at Purple $194 at Amazon

Why we love it: The Purple Harmony is the most feature-filled pillow I tested. It comes with a nylon and spandex outer cover, fantastic for wicking away moisture. Purple’s proprietary honeycomb gel surrounds an inner core of talalay latex for support and structure. The gel essentially gives you the lightness of down with the support of foam that helps the pillow contour around your head without enveloping it and creates space between you and the pillow.

The Harmony did very well in our heat retention test, wicking away 1.2F per minute. I also liked that my head felt bouncy while sleeping on it. It reminds me of the rubber mulch they put in playgrounds to prevent injuries – squishy to a point, then firm.

It’s a shame that: It’s by far the most expensive pillow on this list that I tested, with an average price that hovers at about $200, even when considering sale prices. Yes, the latex core means this is very durable and can be seen as an investment, but you can get very similar performance for less.

Supa Modern Cooling Pillow

Supa Modern
Cooling Pillow
none-selected
Supa Modern Cooling Pillow
  • Amazon $38
$38 at Amazon

The Supa Modern Cooling Pillow is a bit of a niche product, with a “cooling side” and a “soft side”. The cooling does feel cool to the touch. Our heat retention test showed it was about average for wicking away heat. While this option is quite affordable, I found it to be rather thin compared with the competition.

Amazon Basics Firm Pillow

Amazon
Basics Firm Pillow
none-selected
Amazon Basics Firm Pillow
  • Amazon $19
$19 at Amazon

The best way to describe the Amazon Basics Firm Pillow is that it lives up to its name – it’s the most basic expression of a pillow. Its exterior and fill are made from polyester, a material that isn’t known for its breathability. During the compression test, the Basics Firm Pillow didn’t prove to be that firm, compressing down 80% of its loft height. But given the price tag, it’s hard to complain – for a guest bedroom, or when you need something for a dorm room, the Amazon Basics Firm Pillow delivers.

***

What else you need to know about pillows

What should you look for based on your sleep position?

Typically, side sleepers should look for higher-loft pillows that are softer, while back sleepers are best served by medium-loft pillows that are firmer, and stomach sleepers will be most comfortable with low-loft pillows.

What are the differences between the different types of pillow fillings?

Pillows are generally stuffed with three types of filling, all with specific properties for specific needs. Foam provides high amounts of support and breathability, while latex and gel make for a durable pillow with a nice balance of support and softness. And down and its alternatives are soft, warm and generally shapable, but will not give you the support of the other two.

How do you wash pillows?

As a rule of thumb, most outer casings can be thrown in the washing machine on a gentle cycle with warm water and a small amount of detergent. Foam and latex pillow cores can only be spot-cleaned.

Down and down alternative pillows can often be machine-washed in their entirety.

However, always check the care tags and follow the instructions.

What pillows are best for hot sleepers?

Foam and latex tend to be better for heat dissipation. Real down tends to trap warmth. You should also pick a breathable and moisture-wicking pillowcase material such as cotton or linen.

What is an adjustable pillow?

If you see a pillow advertised as adjustable, it usually means you can remove or add filling to adjust the height of the pillow to align with your body.

* * *

Other pieces you might enjoy from the Filter, the Guardian’s guide to buying fewer, better things:

Explore the Filter  

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*